Wednesday, December 22, 2010

Final Project: Tectonic Plates

Section I: The Lesson Rationale
       "Miguel, did you know that if you lie on the ground and stay very still, you can feel the earth's heart beating?"  She bent over and touched the grass. ... She lay down on her stomach and patted the ground next to her. ... She watch Miguel watching her. And then she felt it. Beginning softly. A gentle thumping, repeating itself. Then stronger. She heard it, too. Shoomp. Shoomp. Shoomp. The earth's heartbeat. Just like she had felt it that day with Papa.
Esperanza Rising by Pam Munoz Ryan

 
    This Blog contains my final project and is a site teachers can use to teach tectonic plates in segments of 30-45 minutes. With so much mandated curriculum it is imperative to find niches of time where science lessons like these can be taught, enjoyed, and valued by all stake holders because it is important to hear earth's heartbeat - she definitely has one!


Layers of the Earth: Plate Tectonics
Overview
http://mceer.buffalo.edu/connected_teaching/lessons/plateTectonics.html

   * This lesson explores the basics of plate tectonics, and the layers of the earth.
Estimated Time:  45 minutes


Materials
    * Cantaloupe (Engagement Activity)
    * Compasses
    * Coloring Supplies (Markers, Colored Pencils, Crayons)
    * Graham Crackers
    * 2 Knives (one sharp knife to cut the Cantaloupe, one butter knife to make the PB & J and graham cracker sandwich)
    * 11” x 17” paper
    * Paper Towels (for clean up)
    * Peanut Butter and Jelly
    * Pens and Pencils
    * Rulers

Objectives
    * Students will be able to identify the different properties of each layer of the earth.
    * Students will be able to explain in their own words the movement of plates.

National Standards Addressed

Math (Presented by National Council of Teachers of Mathematics in 2000)
    Geometry
        * Use visualization, spatial reasoning, and geometric modeling to solve problems.
    Measurement
        * Understand measurable attributes of objects and the units, systems, and processes of measurement.
        * Apply appropriate techniques, tools, and formulas to determine measurements.

    Connections
        * Recognize and apply mathematics in contexts outside of mathematics.

    Representation
        * Use representations to model and interpret physical, social, and mathematical phenomena.

 Science (Presented by National Research Council in 1996)
    Unifying Concepts and Processes
        * Change, constancy, and measurement

    Physical Science
 * Motions and forces.

    Earth and Space Science
        * Structure of the earth system.


    Science in Personal and Social Perspectives
        * Natural Hazards : A must view link to Teacher’s Domain Earth Quake Prediction

Cultural
        *Culturally knowledgeable students are able to engage effectively in learning activities that are based on traditional ways of knowing and learning

Technology (Presented by the International Society for Technology in Education in 1998)
    Technology problem-solving and decision-making tool
         * Students use technology resources for solving problems and making informed decisions.
         * Students employ technology in the development of strategies for solving problems in the real world.

Section II: The Lesson
Engagement Activity
    *Read Skeleton Woman to the class and draw an analogy between Earth and the traits of humans
    * Gather all students around a table where they can all see.
    * Cut a cantaloupe in half, or have done so before class.
    * Ask students to identify the number of layers, and to give properties of each (e.g. the center most layer is squishy and like liquid, while the outermost layer is tough and looks like rock).

Instructional Plan

    * Hand out 11” by 17” paper to students, along with compasses and rulers.
    * Explain that much like the cantaloupe, the earth has many layers, each with it’s own properties.
    * Write the following information (chart 1) on the depth of each layer where all students can see it.

Chart 1
Layer             Depth from the Earth’s Surface        Layer Thickness
Crust                             30 km                                             30 km
Mantle                          30-2890 km                                    2860 km
Outer Core                   2890-5150 km                                 2260 km
Inner Core                    5    150-6378 km                            1228 km

  
    * As either individuals or small groups have students determine a scale to use so that they can draw a diagram of these layers on their 11” by 17” paper.
    * After students are finished drawing the layers, and labeling them accordingly, pass out coloring supplies.
    * Relating the layers of the earth back to the layers of the cantaloupe discuss the properties of the layers of the earth. Refer to chart 2 below for more information on this.


Chart 2
     Layer    
Properties for the                                                              Properties for the
earth layer                                                                          cantaloupe layer
Crust   Solid surface, with great expanses of water        Solid surface, rough

Mantle Solid and liquid (like magma), ranges             Solid and liquid, green
in temperature from 1000-5000° C

Outer
Core Liquid, scientists think it’s made of iron,          Solid and liquid, orange
 ranges in temperature from 5000-6200° C                 fruit (the part you eat)


Inner
Core Solid, made of Iron and Nickel, ranging          Solid, liquid, gas (seedy
in temperature from 6200-6700° C                            mess that you scoop out)
                                                                                     

    * Have students take notes on their diagrams, or on the back, to indicate the properties of each layer.
    * Set diagrams aside.
    * Gather students around a common table so all can see.
    * Using graham crackers, peanut butter, and jelly (peanut butter can be removed from this activity if students have peanut allergies), make a sandwich. Be sure to use a thick layer of jelly.
    * Holding the sandwich up (layering graham cracker, jelly, peanut butter, then graham cracker), push slightly down on the top graham cracker, sliding it over the jelly.
    * Explain the earth has similar motion. On top of the solid and liquid core and mantle sits solid plates. They move on the surface, very slowly, but they move. Sometimes colliding into each other. Much like bumper cars at an amusement park in slow motion.

Concluding:

    * Have students discuss and explore other common items with layers, relating these layers to the layers of the earth.
    * Consider an orange, an apple, an avocado, a hard-boiled egg, a baseball, a golf ball, or a lacrosse ball.

Evaluation and Assessment

Students will be able to:
    * Diagram the layers of the earth.
    * Explain the movement of plates.

Extending

    * Convert scales from °C to °F, and from kilometer to miles
    * Earthquakes
 Explore Internet sites for other information on the layers of the earth


E-Resources, Print Materials, and Hands-on Activities

    * New York State Regents Reference Tables for Earth Science
    * Web Sources for Plate Tectonics, Earth Science, & Seismology Resources


Section III: Resources & Extending Activities

o What's Shakin' : Additional lessons that build upon this one.
 o Peek into the Earth : A background read about working in the crust.

º 1964 Alaska Earthquake  :Teacher’s Domain video

º Tectonic Plate Movement in Alaska :Teacher’s Domain video
º Tectonic Plates, Earthquakes, and Volcanoes : Teacher’s Domain video

º Earthquake Prediction : Teacher’s Domain video


    

Section IV:  Books Worth Reading or Buying


Books:
Earthquakes, by Sally Walker (Carolrhoda Books, 1996)
    She has wonderful books that children and adults can’t resist.

Journey to the Center of the Earth
    A classic read (all here)– captivating, intriguing, and a testimony to the human imagination.

Websites:
www.exploratorium.edu/faultline
    A wonderful primary source of earthquakes: Great Shakes, Quake Basics, Damage Control, and Active Zone (activities teachers can reproduce to demonstrate quakes).

Skeleton Woman by Alberto Villoldo

Friday, December 3, 2010

IX: Climate, Terrestrial Ice and Alaskan Indigenous Cultures

Essential Question:
How are climate, terrestrial ice and Alaskan indigenous cultures all connected?


Explain:
       WOW!! Out of 1000 drops of water 972 are in the oceans and inland seas! What a remarkable statistic. It really puts the oceans in perspective, and boggles my mind that we know so little about oceans when they are the majority of Earth. The amount of ice in Antarctica also surprised me.
       These facts about water reminded me of an Ocean 7 Essential Principles poster I saw.  It was beautiful and made me stop and think, so I copied the text to tuck away for future use. The principles were:
1. Earth has one big ocean.
2. The ocean shapes the Earth.
3. The ocean influences Earth’s climate.
4. The ocean makes Earth livable.
5. The ocean supports a diversity of life and ecosystems.
6. The ocean is connected to us and we are connected to it.
7. The ocean is largely unexplored.
       Once again the theme of connectedness is empathized. I never fully realized just how interconnected and fragile our planet is until this last module. Facts were building as I read the modules and my schema was being developed, but I just never really thought a lot about how everything is really just one big system. When one part is disturbed it has a ripple effect throughout the system.
       It seems only man goes about obliviously thinking all is well when in fact the Earth is shaking her fist and sending all sorts of warning signs that it isn’t well. I can see why stewardship is such a big component in organizations and education today.


Cultural Connections:

         The Traditional Tlingit Country map with the tribes, clans, and clan houses is an incredible resource. It lays out the organizational structure of the Tlingit people and reaffirms that Native knowledge is passed down through language. When the language is lost, the heart of the culture goes with it.
        The melting permafrost poses a real problem as lakes disappear. New species encroach on traditional species causing the landscape to under go change. It was very disheartening to see the trees leaning over due to melting permafrost. Waterfowl that depend upon the lakes and bogs to exist are in danger because nesting and feeding grounds are no longer there due to melting permafrost. The picture book If You Were a Wild Duck Where Would You Go came immediately to mind as I reflected upon this module.
       The “positive feedback loop” is actually a “negative feedback loop” when the effects are considered. I applaud Arctic Village because they are trying the solar panels as an alternative energy source. Any alternative energy source is expensive whether it be wind, water, or solar sources but they should be considered well worth the investment. Thirty-five million dollars yearly in Alaska alone to fix the melting permafrost problems can go along way toward alternative energy.
       Melting permafrost solutions are in the works, but they are costly and not a full scale solution. This link looks at the Trans Alaska Oil Pipeline sinking and how a snow machine might be the answer.

Extend:
       We as teachers really need to make students aware of what is happening to Earth's surfaces and climate. Kids want to help and they believe they can make a difference so getting them involved makes sense.
       This was a terrific module! I have bookmarked many of the sites and I have an idea forming in my mind of how to use the information gleaned from this course. My tentative idea is to buy cheap pull-down window shades and have students create murals on them of ways they and their families can help Mother Earth in her struggle to be healthy. They can even hang things on the murals with captions like, "If you see this throw it away."

Technology:
A book, old fashioned technology, that discusses the role of being a steward


A great site for kids and stewardship











Another miracle of nature just keeping us humble!






Creating Inquiry:

A Habitat Made By Me!  This is a link that provides instructions for making an eco-column. I've done this one and kids really love it. I have found that white clouds work better than goldfish since their urine isn't so acidic.


Three Colleague:
•   Lila Lee Little blog on Atmospheric Systems was very interesting. Her site Biomagnification in Lake Ontario was also something I would use with students.

•  Kevin Hamrick  I liked his voice. I could relate to what he was saying in Module VII. It does seem like we are having warmer winters and the weather doesn't seem nearly as cold as when I was young. I remember one winter in McGrath the thermometer hit -72ºF at the airport - and we still went out and played!


•  Doug Armstrong  I loved his pictures and I especially enjoyed his pictures of the ice melting in the glasses.

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Module VIII - Cryosphere

 Live From the North Pole: 
"The value of research coupled with nature's
own wondrous display"
Explain
         This module focuses on the Arctic sea ice and the term cryoshpere, which was new to me.  I learned several things about the cryosphere during this exploration and enjoyed it very much. This coming week I'm attending a symposium on placed based learning in New Bedford, MA, so this module couldn't have been more appropriately placed. 
         I found the article:  “When Contemporary Science and Indigenous Knowledge  Collide: Two     Ways of Knowing How to Survive and Thrive as the Climate  Changes,” very insightful. That coupled with with the Anchorage Declaration renewed the commitment we must all make if indigenous peoples all over the globe are to survive with any authenticity. They are pleading with the global community to validate their way of life and to recognize their right to retain a life style unique to their cultures.
        When a people have a traditional heritage that becomes threatened because of an endangered species being over harvested then I believe compromises need to be made. This is important for the heritage to continue. 
       For example, when I was a little girl I remember loving beaver feet. Beaver feet was a real treat. My family moved away from the area and I haven't eaten beaver feet in 20+ years. They no longer have a draw for me, and that is sad. Beaver are not endangered, but I offer this example trying to show how restricting the harvesting of traditional foods for indigenous people can affect future generations. My kids have never tasted beaver feet, and if they do they almost certainly will not like it like my traditional uncle and his family do. Culture dies when its traditions are not generational.
       
Cultural Connections: 
  "Let us walk softly upon the earth for it does not belong to us, but to our children and their children and their children and ..."



  • People of the Arctic    This site has several resources concerning Alaska Native Perspectives on Land and Climate with clips on the cryosphere. It also offers lesson plans and student activities. 
    •  Lessons and Activities about Arctic Peoples This is a great site for teachers wondering just how to teach a unit on Arctic peoples. It will help "...your students understand that the indigenous cultures of the Arctic - like other cultures of the world - change over time, incorporating modern technology while retaining traditional values and activities? In this article, we've highlighted resources that can help you design a lesson or unit about Arctic cultures."

    Extend 

    I am going to use the experiments with the ice cubes melting in the glass and the one with two glasses -  one covered in white and the other in black paper. I'll do this when I return as I am out all of next week. I bookmarked the page. So, I'm not sure if my graphs will make it onto the blog or not. Time is running out. I'm wondering if this site will remain up so it can be accessed after the class is over? I know I would use it. I wonder at the time Clay must put in to find the  resources and write the modules!

    Technology: 
     Several great selections.
    Great site for students to see the interconnectedness for species.

    Creating Inquiry:
    This site asks students to identify the challenges involved in building a structure in a remote area of the Arctic. They then build and explore. A wonderful lesson for grades 5 and up.



    Three Colleague:
    • Dave Sather: I loved his "Carl Sagan's Cosmos - Star Stuff" from Module VII. Fabulous resources! 
    • Esther Gust   From Module V. I liked that she is learning as much as I am, and enjoying it. She is even sharing the information with her students, and that's so appropriate as they are on the ocean 
    • Alicia Weaver   I appreciated her photo of Quinhagak. It brings me back to my roots - village Alaska.

    Sunday, November 21, 2010

    Changing Climate

    Module VII
    Essential Question: How is Earth's climate connected to its geological, biological and cultural systems?


    Explain
    “The sun also rises, and the sun goes down, and hastens to the place where it arose. The wind goes toward the south, and turns around to the north; the wind whirls about continually, and comes again on its circuit. All the rivers run into the sea, yet the sea is not full; to the place from which the rivers come, they return again. All things are full of labor; man cannot express it.” Ecclesiastesastes 1: 5-8a

     I could not express the concepts in this week’s module as eloquently as King Solomon, so I used his quote. The last sentence captures the essence of Module VII.

    Our dynamic universe and planet is living. The complexity of cycles, even  positive feedback types,  to stars creating the elements to the microbial factories is fascinating. All of this makes me want to learn more, and possibly, regret not working in a science field. It is very apparent that things seen and unseen are hard at work producing material that affects earth’s climate.

    I learned a lot from this week's module, and added several TD resources to my folders. I didn't know that H and He are the foundational gasses for forming all of the known elements on earth. The video  does a super job of showing how this works. I wish I'd found this out earlier in my teaching career. I think it would have helped my students better understand the earth's elements and the periodic table.

    Cultural Connections:
    It is very difficult to study ancient Athabaskan culture, beyond the 1700’s, because the microorganisms have played their role in the cycling of matter and energy so well. The Athabaskan's used organic material for practically everything: birch for boats, cooking/eating tools, moose and other animals for clothing, wood for housing structures.  They traded for some items and used others like claws, teeth, and bones for amulets, etc. But, finding much evidence of  their daily life has been difficult because their resources were mainly organic, and thus the artifacts are likewise organic and have decomposed.

    There are several Native stories concerning how things came to be or how they will be. One of the most extensive is the story of Maniixaq. It is an Inupiaq, northwest Alaska,  story and it is quite long, but worth the read. A great read aloud for older students. This connection is tied to the science on Module VII through the quest for “intelligence”.

    Extend
    Technology:

    “..and a flash of light filled the cosmos…” Evidence for the Big Bang would be a great introduction for students to the Big Bang Theory as well as the periodic table. Modern technology lends validity to science. Technology has advanced theories to where scientist can prove a hypothesis. This is huge in light of what someone like Galileo had to endure just because he did not have the technology to prove his theories.

    Creating Inquiry:
    The question: How do we know is important. Teachers should not spew scientific "facts" as if the facts are gospel. Students should always be made to question/hypothesize. Teachers and Students also need to consider that as new information is gained, old ideas will be impacted, and the current science "facts" may change. For example, when watching the TD video The Origin of the Elements , students should ask: How do scientist know what elements are being emitted from a super nova? The answer is not in the video. It comes in reading the background essay: "...two elements produce the same colors and line positions along a spectrum. By using instrumentation that reads light signatures from far away — a technique known as spectroscopy — scientists today know with great certainty which elements a planet or a star, or even a star's dispersed remnants, contains." This keeps inquiry alive, and advances thinking – pushing the limits instead of just receiving information verbatim.

    Evaluate:
    I found the resources in this week's module very useful for myself and my teaching. I will definitely use the videos and the background essays. The explanation of greenhouse gasses and the greenhouse effect on earth's climate were outstanding.

    Resources:




     Maniixaq As A Boy listening to
    the bird who guided him to
    "intelligence".


    Maniixaq

    Three Colleague
    Ernestine Hayes
    I loved her quote from Module IV when she talks about events that have impacted earth through time.  ...and some within a history so distant that it is the earth alone who tells the stories

    Tracy R. Pulid
    I loved her Module VI comments and resources. I especially appreciated her comments about the freezing and thawing due to the Chinook winds.

    Dominic (Nick) Pader
    Very good blog about the Arctic haze and the accumulation of "scuz".



    Saturday, November 13, 2010

    Atmospheric Systems
    Essential Question: How are the Earth, atmosphere and cultures all connected?

    Explain
    I thought this week’s module was great. I learned several things and am still puzzled by others.  I take so much for granted as an inhabitant of our terra firma. I knew of currents, but to explore them through the resources Clay provided was fascinating. I gained a new appreciation for the complexity of the elements in my daily life!

    The main idea was currents, oceanic and atmospheric. The simulations on TD were wonderful visuals and provided information in a way that elementary students in grades 3+ could understand and make sense of the phenomenon.

    I thought the cultural connections were scant, but much could be implied or researched. Native people are often thought of, as being good stewards of the land, but one problem every village in Alaska faces is garbage. Open garbage sites in rural villages are a source of pollution for both atmosphere and rivers/lakes/oceans. Many dumps are burned releasing carbons into the atmosphere. Other dump sites are near a water source and items are carried into the water system creating environmental hazards for life in and along the water way.

    The garbage anomaly is in contrast to how precious the water is as it provides so many food sources for native people. It was painful for me to post the picture below of the garbage dump in Barrow, but it highlights a problem that villages are and have been trying to solve for a number of years. I feel, we each can do our part culturally for Mother Earth and dispose of our garbage in a more earth friendly way. It’s everyone’s problem.

    In Google Earth I was astounded to discover the number of satellites orbiting earth.  This is space pollution (I guess I’m on a tangent). I’m wondering if the number of satellites are somehow lending to the greenhouse affect? And, it makes me wonder how the space shuttle is so adept at avoiding collisions with them. I wasn’t able to figure out the weather layers in Google Earth. I’ll have to go back and play around with that more.

    Extend
    I will definitely use many of the resources in my classroom. I have several folders created in TD and add to them with every new module. This weeks’ sites were particularly helpful in explaining weather fronts and ocean currents. Below are new links I found useful. They address the concepts of coastlines, oceans, and the last is a link to Aleut stories and legends. There’s a wonderful story about how the wind originated.

    Three Colleague
    The painting was very intriguing and the information on the explosion of Krakatoa was great.
    Dan Adair 
    I liked his resource image of the currents. He seems very knowledgeable.
    Janet Reed
    She figured out Google Earth and inspired me to go back in and figure it out.

     




    Resources:

    http://www.teachersdomain.org/resource/ess05.sci.ess.earthsys.coastenv/

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LrrJTzXwKx8&feature=player_embedded#!


    Image of garbage dump in Barrow, AK












    http://www.native-languages.org/aleut-legends.htm
    Scroll down to Origin of the Wind: Aleut legend about the doll-warrior who released the winds.




    Friday, November 5, 2010

    Climate, Culture, and Oceans

    Oceans
    Essential Question:
    How are climate, cultures and oceans all connected?

    Oceans
    Essential Question:
    How are climate, cultures and oceans all connected?



        Climate, culture, and oceans are so connected it is like asking how arms and legs impact the body. One isn’t complete without the other. Oceans cause climate while climate influences oceans, and culture evolves, adapts, and utilizes both.
        At this point in the class, after reading, responding, and viewing all of the videos, I am even more in awe of our planet than ever. Our ancestors lovingly, and respectfully said, “Mother Earth” because they sensed the connectedness of everything.  And, as an Athabaskin, this planet “watches” and holds me accountable for my actions or lack of them.


    Three ways I might use the resources in Module V in my classroom:
    1.   You Tube! I really am disappointed that ASD blocks access to You Tube in district classrooms. After watching What causes Earth's Seasons, I was so impressed.  The simplicity of the illustrations and the explained science behind “seasons” was something any kid could get. ( I need to find a way in behind the firewall!)

    2.    I’m also going to use Try this Trick – (I’ve bookmarked it). I am going to use a circular surface and shine a light behind it and then tilt the object to show the shadow gets smaller – less direct surface area to absorb direct hits from our source of physical existence – the sun. I hope this works, as it is so elementary to understanding earth science.

    3.   I didn’t really understand Check Out the ThermoHaloPycnocline Graph Found Here. I understood the whale dive and the difference in temperature and density, but I didn’t get the plot the yellow line because I didn’t see a yellow line ☹. This module was full of information, some advanced and very useful for high school teachers, so I didn’t feel too badly “not getting it”.
      
    Resources:
    Climate videos
        
    Several Climate Videos.
    Preview and download short, broadcast quality video clips on a range climate topics. Each clip is accompanied by a web preview and suggested script.



    Climate change in Alaska

     Bear in Denali National Park.
    One of the many species climate
    may affect in Alaska.











    Three things I learned:

    1.  I had never thought of the different densities of water at the surface, although I knew different densities existed with depth. I’ve certainly observed surface densities mixing when muddy river water met clear mountain streams, but I had never thought about them resisting mingling. My mind’s eye takes me to the muddy Yukon meeting a clear flowing tributary and seeing the clear water hold its own for several hundred feet before being swallowed by the more powerful river. I always felt badly seeing the clear water swirling and mixing and then disappearing, but I had not connected it to the resistance because of differences in density.

    2.  The experiment with the balloons was so eye opening. It really showed how water has such density that it can absorb heat to a large extent. It was a great demonstration of how water holds heat to the earth.

    3.  I also found our that icebergs in the cold regions of earth do not get so heavy that they sink.  It is the salt that gets squeezed out of them as they freeze that settles beneath due to its density. Then when the salty mixture comes up, it replenishs the top layer of the ocean with nutrients. Who would have thought!

    Three colleagues:
    1.    Cheryl Williams. I was impressed with her understanding of the content. So much so that she found humor! I was straining to digest much of the material!

    2.    Dan Adair. I liked his comments of using more visuals in the classroom. They are out there. We just need to find them.

    3.    Janet Reed. I liked her bringing us back to cycles, and I liked her link to Shishmaref and the ocean erosion there.

    Saturday, October 30, 2010

    Module IV

    Three ways I might use the resources in Module IV in my classroom:

    1.    The Teacher Domain sites are invaluable to building a visual understanding for students and teachers alike. They explain the Pacific Rim of Fire visually, which cannot be reproduced in words. Using Google Earth to locate places and to calculate distances is also a wonderful tool to any teacher's toolbox. I will definitely use it.
    2.    I would use the TD and You Tube resources to reinforce the idea that the earth is a dynamic, powerful “being” under our feet. And, many cultural stories stem from trying to make sense of this dynamic, and many times catastrophic, display of power, which occurs as a result of earth’s turmoil with itself. Things we earthlings depend upon to be consistent just isn’t over time. And as such, in ancient times a great respect for Mother Earth was created because she had the power to create and destroy. Today, modern science elevates itself above such reverence, and therein lies the disconnect between academia and culture.
    3.    Resources:
    Volcano Woman
    Volcanoes around the world

    Three things I learned: 
    1. Two types of earth's forces that cause volcanoes: hot spots and plate action;
    2. I know about the controversy on Hawaii over the observatories. I’ve heard speakers for both positions and watched documentaries concerning the cultural history and relevance of the mountain. What was new information for me was the need/desire to build a new structure. I agree with the native traditional perspective. Use what is there – upgrade or whatever, but another structure would not only be an eye sore, but also, negating native Hawaiian traditional values.
    3. How to use the ruler in Google Earth. That was cool! My class is writing to students in Craig, AK so I will go on Google Earth and show them the community and use the ruler to show that Craig is about 733 miles from Anchorage.

    Three colleagues:
    Ernestine Hayes.
     I appreciate her cultural comments and her perspective on land. I also love her comments, which include comments from Paul Marks. All indigenous people lived by the moon. We Native people have 13 lunar cycles to our year. The western way of thinking had to cram 2 full moons into one month to make all of the full moons fit into a 12 month year. And when 2 full moons occur in one month we say, "Once in a blue moon". How blue got associated with 2 full moons in one month is a story I don't know.
    Konrad Mittelstadt.
    I really liked Konrad’s research into traditional stories.  His relaying of the Tlingit legends of a monster frog living in the bay that created a death trap is so relevant to me. Native people have observed phenomenon, and their stories tell “tales” if the listener can make the conscientious link between culture and “science”.
    Tracy R. Pulido.
     I liked her humor laced with  a reality check. I think all of us who have survived from the land feel we have a reasonable chance of making it if the world does go to “hell”.